NiruttipathasuttaThe Scope of Definition
Sāvatthinidānaṁ.
sāvatthinidānaṁ tayome → sāvatthiyaṁ tayo me (bj); (pts) | sāvatthinidānaṁ → sāvatthī tatra kho (sya-all)At Sāvatthī.
“Tayome, bhikkhave, niruttipathā adhivacanapathā paññattipathā asaṅkiṇṇā asaṅkiṇṇapubbā, na saṅkīyanti, na saṅkīyissanti, appaṭikuṭṭhā samaṇehi brāhmaṇehi viññūhi.
appaṭikuṭṭhā → appatikuṭṭhā (bj) | saṅkīyanti → saṅkiyanti (sya-all) | saṅkīyissanti → saṅkiyissanti (sya-all) | saṁkīyanti → Missing in S3 (pts note) | saṁkīyissanti → Omitted by S3; B samkiyy-; S1 saññi- here only; further on saṁkīy- as S1 (pts note) | tayome → tayo me (bjt) | asaṅkiṇṇā asaṅkiṇṇapubbā → asaṁkiṇṇā asaṁkiṇṇapubbā (ms2005, pts)“Mendicants, there are these three scopes of definition, labeling, and description. They’re uncorrupted, as they have been since the beginning. They’re not being corrupted now, nor will they be. Sensible ascetics and brahmins don’t look down on them.
Katame tayo?What three?
Yaṁ, bhikkhave, rūpaṁ atītaṁ niruddhaṁ vipariṇataṁ ‘ahosī’ti tassa saṅkhā, ‘ahosī’ti tassa samaññā, ‘ahosī’ti tassa paññatti;
yaṁ → yaṁ hi (pts) | hi → Missing in B (pts note) | rūpaṁ → rūpam (pts) | vipariṇataṁ → vipariṇatam (pts)When form has passed, ceased, and perished, its designation, label, and description is ‘was’.
na tassa saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tassa saṅkhā ‘bhavissatī’ti.
atthīti → atthiti (bj)It’s not ‘is’ or ‘will be’.
Yā vedanā atītā niruddhā vipariṇatā ‘ahosī’ti tassā saṅkhā, ‘ahosī’ti tassā samaññā, ‘ahosī’ti tassā paññatti;When feeling … na tassā saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tassā saṅkhā ‘bhavissatī’ti.
ye saṅkhārā atītā niruddhā vipariṇatā ‘ahesun’ti tesaṁ saṅkhā, ‘ahesun’ti tesaṁ samaññā, ‘ahesun’ti tesaṁ paññatti;
tesaṁ → tesam (pts)choices …
na tesaṁ saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tesaṁ saṅkhā ‘bhavissantī’ti.
bhavissantīti → bhavissatīti (pts) | bhavissatīti → So all the MSS. (pts note)
Yaṁ viññāṇaṁ atītaṁ niruddhaṁ vipariṇataṁ, ‘ahosī’ti tassa saṅkhā, ‘ahosī’ti tassa samaññā, ‘ahosī’ti tassa paññatti;
viññāṇaṁ → viññāṇam (pts)consciousness has passed, ceased, and perished, its designation, label, and description is ‘was’.
na tassa saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tassa saṅkhā ‘bhavissatī’ti.It’s not ‘is’ or ‘will be’.
Yaṁ, bhikkhave, rūpaṁ ajātaṁ apātubhūtaṁ, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassa saṅkhā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassa samaññā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassa paññatti;
yaṁ → yam (pts) | ajātaṁ apātubhūtaṁ → ajātam apātubhūtam (pts)When form is not yet born, and has not yet appeared, its designation, label, and description is ‘will be’.
na tassa saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tassa saṅkhā ‘ahosī’ti.It’s not ‘is’ or ‘was’.
Yā vedanā ajātā apātubhūtā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassā saṅkhā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassā samaññā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassā paññatti;When feeling … na tassā saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tassā saṅkhā ‘ahosī’ti.
ye saṅkhārā ajātā apātubhūtā, ‘bhavissantī’ti tesaṁ saṅkhā, ‘bhavissantī’ti tesaṁ samaññā, ‘bhavissantī’ti tesaṁ paññatti;
bhavissantīti → B bhavissatīti (pts note) | tesaṁ → tesam (pts)choices …
na tesaṁ saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tesaṁ saṅkhā ‘ahesun’ti.
ahesunti → ahesun ti (pts)
Yaṁ viññāṇaṁ ajātaṁ apātubhūtaṁ, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassa saṅkhā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassa samaññā, ‘bhavissatī’ti tassa paññatti;
viññāṇaṁ ajātaṁ apātubhūtaṁ → viññāṇam ajātam apātubhūtam (pts)consciousness is not yet born, and has not yet appeared, its designation, label, and description is ‘will be’.
na tassa saṅkhā ‘atthī’ti, na tassa saṅkhā ‘ahosī’ti.It’s not ‘is’ or ‘was’.
Yaṁ, bhikkhave, rūpaṁ jātaṁ pātubhūtaṁ, ‘atthī’ti tassa saṅkhā, ‘atthī’ti tassa samaññā, ‘atthī’ti tassa paññatti;
atthīti → S1-3 atthi (pts note) | yaṁ → yam (pts) | jātaṁ → jātam (pts)When form has been born, and has appeared, its designation, label, and description is ‘is’.
na tassa saṅkhā ‘ahosī’ti, na tassa saṅkhā ‘bhavissatī’ti.It’s not ‘was’ or ‘will be’.
Yā vedanā jātā pātubhūtā, ‘atthī’ti tassā saṅkhā, ‘atthī’ti tassā samaññā, ‘atthī’ti tassā paññatti;
tassā → tassa (pts)When feeling …
na tassā saṅkhā ‘ahosī’ti, na tassā saṅkhā ‘bhavissatī’ti.
tassā → tassa (pts)
ye saṅkhārā jātā pātubhūtā, ‘atthī’ti tesaṁ saṅkhā, ‘atthī’ti tesaṁ samaññā, ‘atthī’ti tesaṁ paññatti;
atthīti → So all the MSS. (pts note) | tesaṁ → tesam (pts)choices …
na tesaṁ saṅkhā ‘ahesun’ti, na tesaṁ saṅkhā, ‘bhavissantī’ti.
ahesunti → ahesun ti (pts)
Yaṁ viññāṇaṁ jātaṁ pātubhūtaṁ, ‘atthī’ti tassa saṅkhā, ‘atthī’ti tassa samaññā, ‘atthī’ti tassa paññatti;
jātaṁ pātubhūtaṁ → jātam pātubhūtam (pts)consciousness has been born, and has appeared, its designation, label, and description is ‘is’.
na tassa saṅkhā ‘ahosī’ti, na tassa saṅkhā ‘bhavissatī’ti.It’s not ‘was’ or ‘will be’.
Ime kho, bhikkhave, tayo niruttipathā adhivacanapathā paññattipathā asaṅkiṇṇā asaṅkiṇṇapubbā, na saṅkīyanti, na saṅkīyissanti, appaṭikuṭṭhā samaṇehi brāhmaṇehi viññūhi.
appaṭikuṭṭhā → appatikuṭṭhā (bj) | saṅkīyanti → saṅkiyanti (sya-all) | saṅkīyissanti → saṅkiyissanti (sya-all) | asaṅkiṇṇā asaṅkiṇṇapubbā → asaṁkiṇṇā asaṁkiṇṇapubbā (ms2005, pts) | saṅkīyanti → saṁkīyant (pts) | saṅkīyissanti → saṁkīyissanti (pts)These are the three scopes of definition, labeling, and description. They’re uncorrupted, as they have been since the beginning. They’re not being corrupted now, nor will they be. Sensible ascetics and brahmins don’t look down on them.
Yepi te, bhikkhave, ahesuṁ ukkalā vassabhaññā ahetukavādā akiriyavādā natthikavādā, tepime tayo niruttipathe adhivacanapathe paññattipathe na garahitabbaṁ nappaṭikkositabbaṁ amaññiṁsu.
nappaṭikkositabbaṁ amaññiṁsu → na paṭikkositabbaṁ maññiṁsu (bj) | ukkalā vassabhaññā ahetukavādā → ukkalāvassabhaññā ahetuvādā (pts) | nappaṭikkositabbaṁ → na patikkositabbaṁ (pts) | vassabhaññā → okkalā vayabhiññā (cck: ma. ni. 3.343) | ahetuvādā → B ahetukavādā (pts note) | yepi → ye pi (pts) | tepime → te pi me (pts)Even those who were loud and bold advocates of the doctrines of no-cause, inaction, and nihilism, didn’t imagine that these three scopes of definition should be criticized or rejected.
Taṁ kissa hetu?Why is that?
Nindāghaṭṭanabyārosaupārambhabhayā”ti.
Nindāghaṭṭanabyārosaupārambhabhayā”ti → nindābyārosaupārambhabhayāti (bj, sya-all, km, pts1ed) | nindāghaṭṭanabyārosaupārambhabhayāti majjhimapaṇṇāsakassa → nindābyārosaupārambhabhayāti (bj) | nindāghaṭṭanabyārosaupārambhabhayāti → nindābyārosaupārambhabhayāti (sya-all, pts) | Nindāghaṭṭanabyārosaupārambhabhayā’’ti → nindābyārosaupārambhabhayāti (sī. syā. kaṁ. pī.) ma. ni. 3.343 (cck note) | pathamo → Omitted by S1; S3 samatto (pts note) | nindāghaṭṭanabyārosaupārambhabhayāti → nindāvyārosa-upārambhabhayā ti majjhima-paṇṇāsakassa upāyavaggo pathamo (pts)For fear of being blamed, attacked, provoked, and faulted.”
Majjhimapaṇṇāsakassa upayavaggo paṭhamo.
majjhimapaṇṇāsakassa → (cck) | paṭhamo → chaṭṭho (cck) | upayavaggo → upāyavaggo (th)
Upayo bījaṁ udānaṁ, upādānaparivattaṁ;
upayo → upāyo (sya-all) | udānaṁ upādānaparivattaṁ → upādānaṁ parivaṭṭaṁ (sya-all) | upayo bījaṁ udānaṁ → upāyo bījam udānam (pts) upādānam → S1-3 -nañca (pts note) | upādānaparivattaṁ → upādānaparivaṭṭañca (bjt) | upādānaparivattaṁ → parivaṭṭaṁ (th) | upādānaparivattaṁ → upādānam parivaṭṭaṁ (pts) Sattaṭṭhānañca sambuddho, pañcamahāli ādittā;
sambuddho pañcamahāli ādittā vaggo → buddho pañcavaggi mahalī āditto (sya-all) | ca → Omitted by S1-3 (pts note) | Sambuddho → S1-3 Buddho (pts note) | sattaṭṭhānañca sambuddho → sattaṭṭhānaṁ buddho (bjt) | sattaṭṭhānañca → sattaṭṭhānaṁ ca (pts) pañca → S1-3 add vaggi (pts note) | Ādittā → S1-3 -tto (pts note) | pañcamahāli ādittā → pañcavaggi mahāli (bjt) | pañcamahāli ādittā → pañcavaggi mahalī (th) | pañcamahāli → pañca mahāli (pts) Vaggo niruttipathena cāti.
cāti → cā ti sāvatthi (pts) | Vaggo → In B only (pts note) | Niruttipathena → S1 -pañcena (pts note) | ti → S1-3 vāti (pts note) | vaggo niruttipathena cāti → āditto niruttipathenacāti (bjt) | vaggo → āditto (th)